The Things That Follow You - Installment Four: The Things She Knows

 

The Things That Follow You

A Penny Dreadful · Installment Four

Dear reader,

There is nothing quite so unsettling as discovering that a stranger knows something about you that you never told them.

It changes the character of ordinary things. A knock at the door becomes a question. A car parked across the street becomes a possibility. Even the familiar comfort of home begins to feel conditional, as though safety is something that can be withdrawn without notice.

Melody Hart had spent the last few days trying to convince herself that the trouble at Whitmore, Hale & Pierce could be explained. A misunderstanding. A cruel office politics game. A woman who had taken the arrival of a new colleague rather more personally than was reasonable.

She was still working on that explanation when her phone rang.



Chapter Four: The Things She Knows

Melody let it ring twice before answering.

The number was unfamiliar. Nashville had been full of unfamiliar numbers lately—recruiters, apartment management, people calling about utilities she had already set up. There was no reason this one should have felt different.

And yet she watched the screen until the third ring, as though the name might appear if she waited long enough.

“Hello?”

For a moment, there was only a faint hiss of static.

Then a woman said, “Melody Hart?”

“Yes. Who is this?”

“My name doesn't matter. What matters is that you listen to me.”

Melody sat a little straighter on the sofa. Across the room, the city glowed through the apartment windows, all those lit rooms and moving headlights giving the impression that the world was carrying on quite normally without her.

“I don't generally take instructions from unidentified callers,” she said.

“Then I'll try to make this worth your time. Caroline Voss has been asking questions about you.”

Melody's fingers tightened around the phone.

“What sort of questions?”

“Where you lived before Nashville. Whether you have family nearby. Who you talk to outside the office.”

“Why would she want to know any of that?”

“Because she doesn't like surprises.”

It was such an ordinary answer that Melody almost laughed. She had expected something more dramatic, some explanation that would make the strange phone call feel less like a conversation with a person who had watched too many crime documentaries.

Instead, it sounded like office politics.

Only office politics had never, until now, followed her home.

“Who are you?” Melody asked again.

“I used to work at the firm.”

“Did you work with Caroline?”

A pause.

“Yes.”

“Then why should I believe you?”

“You shouldn't believe me just because I say so. That's the trouble with this place. People decide who's credible based on who smiles at them in the hallway.”

Melody glanced toward the front door.

The deadbolt was in place. She had checked it when she came home, then checked it again after setting down her keys. She had also pulled the curtains in the bedroom, although she couldn't remember exactly when she'd started doing that.

“What do you want me to do?” she asked.

“Keep copies of everything. Emails. Messages. Anything that seems wrong. Don't rely on the firm's systems to preserve it for you.”

“That's very specific advice from someone who won't give me her name.”

“I know how this sounds.”

“Do you?”

Another pause, longer this time.

“I should never have waited so long to call you.”

Before Melody could ask what that meant, the woman hung up.

Melody remained still, phone pressed to her ear, listening to the dead line.

Then she lowered it and looked at the screen.

No name. No company. No indication of who had just called her or why.

She opened her email and began searching for Caroline's messages. There were plenty of them, all cheerful and professional, each one a little reminder of how thoroughly Caroline had inserted herself into Melody's first weeks at the firm.

Happy to help!

Just checking in.

Let me know if you need anything at all.

Melody read them again, this time paying attention to the dates, the attachments, the small details she'd overlooked when she still believed Caroline was simply being kind.

One message stood out.

It had arrived two days before the incident, at 7:14 p.m., long after Melody had left the office.

The subject line read: A quick favor.

There was no attachment. The body contained only a single sentence.

I took care of that little issue for you.

Melody stared at it.

She searched her memory. She couldn't remember asking Caroline to take care of anything. She couldn't remember what the issue might have been.

She checked the message details, then the surrounding emails. Nothing explained it.

Perhaps it referred to a scheduling problem. Perhaps it was a routine office matter that had slipped her mind.

Perhaps.

She was beginning to hate that word.

A soft sound came from the hallway outside her apartment.

Melody looked up.

Footsteps passed her door, slowed, then continued toward the stairwell. She waited until she heard the outer door close before moving again.

She told herself that people walked through hallways. That neighbors came and went. That a building full of apartments was not going to fall silent simply because she had begun paying attention.

Then she noticed the envelope beneath her front door.

It was plain white, with no stamp and no return address. Her name was written across the front in neat, careful handwriting.

Melody Hart.

She did not touch it immediately.

Instead, she stood several feet away and studied the envelope as if it might offer an explanation on its own.

Eventually, she crouched and picked it up by the edge.

Inside was a single photograph.

It showed the entrance to her apartment building, taken from across the street. The angle was low and slightly crooked, as though the photographer had been sitting inside a parked car.

The photograph had been taken at night.

Melody recognized the clothes she was wearing. A pale blouse. Dark trousers. Her work bag over one shoulder.

She was unlocking the front door.

On the back of the photograph, someone had written a message in black ink.

You should be more careful about who you trust.

Melody felt the room tilt—not dramatically, not enough to make her fall, but enough to leave her gripping the edge of the console table.

She turned the photograph over again.

There was no date. No signature. Nothing that would tell her who had taken it or why they had chosen to leave it.

She went to the window and pulled the curtain aside by an inch.

The street below was quiet. A delivery van idled near the corner. A man walked a dog beneath the streetlights. Two cars sat along the curb, neither of them unusual enough to remember.

She let the curtain fall.

Then she locked the door again.

For the next hour, Melody did what she had always done when something frightened her: she tried to make it manageable.

She photographed the envelope and the note. She saved the email to a personal account. She wrote down the time of the phone call and everything she could remember about the woman's voice.

She even made a list of possible explanations.

The photograph could have been taken by a private investigator. Caroline might have hired someone to frighten her. The message could have come from the anonymous caller, who might be trying to make Caroline look worse than she was.

Or the person who had sent it might have been someone entirely different.

That last possibility was the one she couldn't quite bring herself to write down.

At 10:38 p.m., her phone lit up.

An unknown number.

One message.

Did you get the photograph?

Melody stared at the screen.

A second message arrived before she could respond.

Don't call the police. You don't know who you're dealing with.

She didn't answer.

Instead, she took screenshots of both messages and sent them to her personal email. Then she placed the phone on the table and slowly backed away from it.

For the first time since arriving in Nashville, she considered the possibility that leaving the city might be the only sensible thing to do.

The thought brought relief, followed almost immediately by shame.

She had worked hard for this job. She had moved her life across state lines. She had signed a lease, bought furniture, learned the route to the office. She had imagined herself settling in, making friends, building something stable.

She hadn't imagined being frightened in her own living room.

She looked again at the photograph.

The person who had taken it had been close enough to see her face. Close enough to watch her reach for her keys. Close enough to know when she came home.

And someone had kept the picture.

Someone had decided that she needed to see it.

Melody placed the photograph inside a folder and wrote the date on the tab.

Then, beneath it, she added three words.

Who knows what?

She sat back and looked at the folder.

It was a small thing, a label on a piece of cardboard. But it was something she could control. Something she could organize, preserve, and return to when the world began to feel unreliable.

She would not let herself be talked out of what she had seen.

She would not let anyone tell her that the photograph was harmless before they had even bothered to ask how it got there.

And she would not forget the message.

You should be more careful about who you trust.

Outside, a car door closed.

Melody went still.

Through the gap in the curtains, she watched a dark sedan pull away from the curb and disappear into traffic.

She couldn't see who had been inside.

She couldn't prove it had anything to do with her.

But when she turned back toward the room, she found herself wondering whether the person who had left the photograph had been sitting in that car all along.


Dear reader, 

Melody has learned that the trouble at Whitmore, Hale & Pierce may not have ended when she walked out of the office. Someone has photographed her coming home. Someone knows where she lives. And someone has warned her not to trust the people around her.

But there is one question she has yet to ask.

If Caroline Voss is watching Melody, who is watching Caroline?

And why does the thought of that person frighten her more?

Until next time, dear reader, keep your curtains closed—and remember that the person who leaves a warning may not be the person you need to fear.

CK

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Little Girl Who Changed Law and Order

"In Thin Air" - Installment Eight - The Edge

Break a Leg!